The Shotgun Clause: How Commercial Co-Owners Part Ways Without the Partition Act
When co-owners of a commercial property stop agreeing and nobody wants to sell first, two exits are left: a buy-sell clause you wrote before the fallout, or a court application after it. Only one is on your own terms.
A shotgun clause lets one commercial co-owner force a buyout — but who ends up buying, who ends up selling, and what happens if you never wrote one?
A shotgun clause turns a deadlock into a forced, single-price buyout: one co-owner names one price per share, and the other must either buy them out at that price or sell their own share at the same price — their pick, but only those two. It lives in the co-ownership agreement (a shotgun clause, or buy-sell clause), it is contractual rather than statutory, and it settles the split privately, without a court. If the co-owners never wrote one, the fallback is different in kind: Ontario’s Partition Act lets a co-owner ask the court to divide the property or order it sold. So the question isn’t only how you separate — it is whether you separate on terms you set yourselves, or on terms you go to court to obtain.
Source: Ontario’s Partition Act, read via the Government of Ontario’s official e-Laws. Shotgun and buy-sell clauses are contractual, not statutory. General information, not legal advice.
I’m Arthur Zhao. Picture a roof quote for a commercial building that has sat unsigned for two months. The roof needs doing, the number is fair, and one of the two co-owners simply will not put their name on it — not over the roof, but because the two of them stopped agreeing about the building a while ago. Now every decision the property throws off — a tenant wanting to renew, the mortgage coming due, that repair — needs both signatures, and one of them has become a wall.
This is the quiet way a jointly owned commercial property seizes up. Nobody did anything dramatic; the co-owners just cannot move together anymore, and there is no button that cleanly splits a plaza in two. When it reaches that point, how you get out was mostly settled long before the roof quote ever landed — by whether anyone thought to write a shotgun clause into the co-ownership agreement.
→
→
→
→
Why a commercial property freezes when co-owners stop agreeing
Co-owners of a commercial building usually hold title as tenants in common — each owns an undivided share of the whole property, not a specific corner of it. That structure works beautifully while everyone agrees. The problem starts when they don’t.
Leasing decisions, a refinance, a capital repair, and above all a sale all tend to need the co-owners to move together. If one wants out and the other will neither buy them out nor sell, there is no self-help way to simply cut the building in two. The asset can sit in limbo — still generating costs and decisions, with no agreement to make them. That deadlock is the exact problem a shotgun clause is built to prevent.
The shotgun clause: an exit you write before you need it
A shotgun clause — also called a buy-sell clause — is a section of the co-ownership agreement that sets out, in advance, how one co-owner can force a clean separation. The name captures the feel of it: it moves fast, and once it is triggered, someone is bought out. It is not a negotiation that drags on. It is a mechanism with a fixed sequence and a fixed outcome — one side ends up owning the whole thing, the other ends up cashed out.
How a shotgun clause actually fires
The mechanics are deliberately simple, which is most of the point. In broad strokes it runs in three moves.
One co-owner pulls the trigger
The other co-owner must buy or sell — at that same price
The chosen deal closes on terms set in advance
💡 Here is the part I flag before anyone falls in love with how balanced this looks: a shotgun clause quietly favours whoever has the deeper pockets. The mechanic assumes both sides could plausibly buy — but if one co-owner can arrange the cash or financing in weeks and the other cannot, the well-capitalized partner can trigger at a price the other simply cannot afford to match, and so effectively choose the outcome. My advice is to fight over the payment window and the financing conditions when you draft the clause, not when it is fired. A realistic closing timeline and clear financing terms are what keep a buy-sell clause a fair exit, rather than a weapon the richer partner points at the other.
Shotgun clause vs the Partition Act, side by side
The Partition Act route: what you can actually ask a court for
If there is no buy-sell clause — or the co-owners never signed a co-ownership agreement at all — Ontario’s Partition Act is the fallback. In plain terms, any person with an interest in the land can bring an application or action and ask the court for one of two things: to partition the property, meaning physically divide it, or — where a sale would be more advantageous to the parties — to order the property sold under the court’s direction. The Act also allows a co-owner to be compelled to make or suffer that partition or sale, so a reluctant co-owner can be brought into the process rather than simply stonewalling it.
Two narrower situations are worth knowing. If a co-owner has not been heard from for three years or more, the court can appoint a guardian to stand in for that missing interest. And where the co-ownership arose through a will or an intestacy, a proceeding generally cannot begin until one year after the death. Notice the framing throughout: this is what you can ask a court for — not a prediction of how any particular judge would rule on your facts.
⚠️Where this stops being general information: whether a shotgun clause you already signed would prevent, pause, or reshape a co-owner’s Partition Act application depends entirely on the wording of your specific agreement. That is a question for a real estate or litigation lawyer on your actual documents — not something to settle from an article.
One more wrinkle: co-owners of land, or shareholders of a company?
Before you reach for either exit, check how the property is actually held. If you and your partners bought the building in your personal names, you are co-owners of the land, and both paths above are in play. But if you bought it through a corporation, the registered owner on title is the company itself — you own shares in that company, not an undivided share of the land.
The Partition Act is about co-owners of land, so in a corporate hold that particular door may not be the one you are standing at. Your exit there usually lives in the shareholder agreement instead — which is exactly why buy-sell mechanics matter just as much when a company owns the building. Which structure you are in, and what it means for getting out, is worth confirming with your lawyer and accountant before a dispute forces the question.
The practical version
Here is the version I would keep on a sticky note:
- The time to write the exit is before you close together, not after you stop agreeing.
- A workable shotgun clause spells out the trigger, how the single price is set, how long the other side has to respond, and the closing terms — including what happens if the buyer cannot finance.
- Confirm whether you hold the property personally (co-owners of land) or through a company (shareholders) — it changes which exit is even available.
- The Partition Act is the fallback, not the plan. Leaning on it means you are already in a dispute and asking a court to sort it out.
None of this is a substitute for the actual drafting. A buy-sell clause is a handful of paragraphs that decide who keeps a building — have a lawyer write and review it against your specific situation.
ℹ️This is general information for Ontario commercial co-owners — not legal advice, and not a substitute for your own lawyer reviewing your co-ownership agreement and your facts.
- Partition Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.4 — Government of Ontario, official e-Laws consolidation (see ss. 2 and 3(1) on partition or sale)
- Shotgun / buy-sell clauses are contractual mechanisms in a co-ownership or shareholder agreement, not statutory provisions
- General information only, not legal advice — clause drafting and any co-ownership dispute go to a licensed Ontario lawyer
One Owner Won’t Sell: How Ontario’s Partition Act Forces a Sale Among Co-Owners →Pooling Money to Buy Commercial Property: Tenants in Common vs. a Limited Partnership →How Developers Assemble Land: Option Agreements, the Holdout, and What It Means If They Knock on Your Door →Ontario Mortgage Guide →
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a shotgun clause in a co-ownership agreement?
It is a buy-sell provision that lets one co-owner force a clean separation. One owner names a single price; the other must then either buy them out at that price or sell their own share at the same price. Because the person who sets the price cannot choose which side of the deal they end up on, the mechanism pushes both sides toward a number they can accept either way.
What happens if commercial co-owners can’t agree and there is no buy-sell clause?
Then the contractual exit isn’t there, and the fallback is Ontario’s Partition Act. Any co-owner with an interest in the land can bring an application and ask the court either to divide the property or, where a sale would be more advantageous to the parties, to order it sold under the court’s direction.
Can one co-owner force the sale of a commercial property in Ontario?
Under the Partition Act, a co-owner can ask the court to order a sale where a sale would be more advantageous to the parties, and the Act allows a reluctant co-owner to be compelled into the process. What is being described here is what you can ask a court for — how a court would actually rule turns on the specific facts and is a matter for a lawyer.
Does a shotgun clause stop a co-owner from going to court under the Partition Act?
That is exactly the question to take to a lawyer on your specific agreement — a shotgun clause and the Partition Act are different tracks, one contractual and one statutory, and whether a clause you signed limits or reshapes a partition application turns on its wording. What is safe to say: if you have a working buy-sell clause, you have an exit that does not require going to court in the first place.
Does it matter if we own the building through a company instead of personally?
Yes, a great deal. If a corporation owns the building, the company is the registered owner of the land and you own shares — not an undivided share of the land itself. The Partition Act concerns co-owners of land, so in a corporate hold your exit usually lives in the shareholder agreement instead. Confirm your structure with your lawyer before assuming which path applies.
Discover more from GTA Real Estate Broker | Arthur Zhao
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.