跳到主要内容Skip to main content
Commercial · Jul 20, 2026 · 15 min read
📖 Commercial

Pooling Money to Buy Commercial Property: Tenants in Common vs. a Limited Partnership

Before the money moves, decide whose name goes on the deed. That one choice — co-owner or silent investor — quietly settles who gets sued, who can force a sale, and who signs for everyone.

Arthur Zhao · Broker · AZ Real Estate Partners · 2026-07-20
Quick Answer

If a few investors buy a commercial building together, should the ownership be structured as tenants in common or a limited partnership — and what actually changes between them?

It starts with a single question: whose name goes on the deed. As tenants in common (TIC), every investor becomes a registered owner holding an undivided interest — shares can be unequal, and each one sits directly on title. In a limited partnership (LP), the partnership is not a legal entity and cannot hold real property, so only the general partner (GP) holds title; you invest as a limited partner and your name never touches the deed.

From that one fork flow the things that actually matter: who gets sued when something goes wrong, whether you can cash out on your own, and who has authority to sign for the group. Both structures are tax flow-through — income and losses pass straight to the individual owners rather than being taxed at an entity level first — so tax is rarely the deciding factor. Liability, exit, and control are.

(This is about investment-grade commercial property — not the residential or estate sense of tenancy in common.)

Sources: Ontario Limited Partnerships Act (RSO 1990, c. L.16); Partition Act (RSO 1990, c. P.4); structural framing drawn from BLG / Torys public commentary (2024, accessed July 2026)

I am Arthur Zhao. The moment a group of investors agrees on a building, the next question is usually the wrong one: which lawyer do we call to close? The question that should come first is quieter — whose name goes on title, and in what structure.

Because putting everyone on the deed and setting up a partnership are not two flavours of the same thing. One makes you a registered owner, with all the standing and all the exposure that carries. The other tucks you behind a general partner, trading control for a liability shield. The cost of the wrong choice usually stays invisible until year three, when someone wants out or a lawsuit lands.

This is not about which building to buy. It is about the paperwork before the money moves. I will line TIC and the limited partnership up across five axes — title, liability, tax, exit, and control — and then name the line most investors miss: in the eyes of Ontario securities law, your friendly little partnership may be a securities offering.

Step 1: Confirm this is investment property, not residential co-ownership

→

Step 2: Decide whose name goes on title — everyone (TIC) or only the GP (LP)

→

Step 3: Map who gets sued — direct owner vs. shielded investor

→

Step 4: Write the exit rules — sell your share vs. locked by agreement

→

Step 5: Fix who votes and who signs for the group

→

Step 6: Check whether raising the money is selling a security

Axis 1 — Title: a row of owners, or one stand-in

The name tenants in common says it plainly: every investor is a registered owner, each holding an undivided interest in the whole. Three investors at 50/30/20 means three names and three percentages on title — nobody owns a specific room, everyone owns their slice of the entire building.

A limited partnership works the opposite way. Under Ontario law an LP is a relationship, not a legal entity, and cannot hold title to real property — only the general partner can. You put money in as a limited partner and receive partnership units, not a place on the deed. To the outside world the building belongs to the GP; internally, the GP holds it for all the partners.

Everything downstream traces back to this: whether your name is on title is what makes you an owner rather than a funder — and the law hands those two identities very different rights and risks.

Axis 2 — Liability: when someone slips and falls, who is named in the claim

Picture a customer slipping in your plaza, and a statement of claim arriving in the mail.

Under TIC, every registered owner is a candidate defendant. Your name is on title, so you are in range. You are liable in proportion to your share, but you carry an owner’s liability with no shell in front of you.

The limited partnership exists precisely to be that shell. Under the Ontario Limited Partnerships Act, the general partner carries unlimited liability while each limited partner’s exposure is capped at the capital they contributed — in principle, the worst case is losing what you put in, without your other personal assets being reached. This is why, in practice, the GP is often a single-purpose holding company: the unlimited liability is parked in an entity that owns little else.

But that shell has a trip-switch — see the note below.

⚠️Limited liability is conditional, not automatic. Under the Ontario Limited Partnerships Act, a limited partner who takes part in the control of the business can be treated as a general partner and exposed to unlimited liability. The Act carves out safe harbours — examining the books and advising on management, acting as a contractor, agent or employee, or acting as a surety do not count as control. But actually making the day-to-day operating decisions can collapse the shield. You can be a hands-off investor, or you can run the deal — you generally cannot do the second while keeping the protection of the first.

Axis 3 — Tax: the column where the two structures tie

Many investors assume the whole point of a partnership is tax, and agonize over TIC versus LP on that basis. This is the column where they essentially tie.

Both are flow-through structures. The property is not taxed as a separate entity first; rent, depreciation, interest, and gains pass directly to each owner, who reports their share on their own (or their own corporation’s) return. On that fundamental point TIC and LP behave the same — both sidestep the double layer of tax a corporation imposes.

The nuance lives in the details. Losses allocated to a limited partner are constrained by the at-risk rules — you cannot deduct more loss than the amount you actually have at risk in the LP — whereas a tenant in common sits closer to holding the asset directly. The takeaway: do not pick between these two for tax reasons. What should drive the choice is liability, exit, and control. Let your accountant run the numbers for your specific facts.

Axis 4 — Exit: can you open the door on your own

This is the most underestimated column, and the one that most often blows up.

TIC carries a built-in detonator called the Partition Act (Ontario, RSO 1990, c. P.4). Under it, any co-owner — even one holding a small fraction — can ask the court to partition or force a sale of the entire property. A commercial building cannot be sliced in half, so the court typically orders the whole thing sold and the proceeds split by share. Meaning: out of five co-owners, a single one who falls out with the group can use a statute to drag the other four into selling. A co-ownership agreement can restrain this somewhat, but you are pushing against a default right written into legislation, and it may not fully hold.

A limited partnership locks the exit inside the partnership agreement instead. Transferring your LP units usually runs through that agreement — GP consent, a right of first refusal, a lock-up period. The upside: no one can invoke the Partition Act to force everyone out. The cost: your liquidity is held by the agreement, so leaving is less free. One structure lets anyone flip the table; the other says you must ask the table first.

🚨The Partition Act is the most overlooked risk in a TIC deal. Investors assume that holding only 20% means having no leverage — the opposite is true. Under the Partition Act, a minority co-owner has the same right to apply for a forced sale. If any co-owner divorces, goes bankrupt, or dies, that co-owner — or their creditors or estate — can trip the detonator and pull the whole building into a forced sale. Skipping a detailed exit clause hands the fate of the entire project to your least stable partner.

Axis 5 — Control: who has authority to sign for the group

The two structures distribute decision-making on opposite philosophies.

TIC defaults to every owner is equal, and big moves need everyone. Each co-owner is a full owner, so major decisions — refinancing, a large capital renovation, selling the building — generally require the parties to agree. That is democracy when the group is aligned and paralysis when it splits: one dissenting co-owner can stall the whole thing. Which is why a serious TIC almost always needs a tightly drafted co-ownership agreement spelling out voting thresholds and who handles day-to-day management.

A limited partnership concentrates management in the GP. Under the Ontario Limited Partnerships Act, the GP controls operations and owes a fiduciary duty to the partnership, deciding on everyone’s behalf, while limited partners deliberately stay clear of daily operations — remember, touching control can cost the liability shield. You gain efficiency and peace of mind; you give up a vote. Choosing an LP is, in essence, handing the wheel to the GP and betting the GP is worth trusting.

💡 One line to hold onto: TIC is five captains steering one ship — everyone is on the deed, everyone has a say, everyone carries the risk, and anyone can abandon it. A limited partnership is one captain and a set of financiers — only the GP is out front, you are below deck, shielded and hands-free, but the wheel is not yours. Neither is inherently better; only one fits your particular group and your particular building.

The line most investors miss: you may be selling a security

The five axes above are about property and governance. But one line runs across both structures and is routinely missed — securities law.

Under Ontario securities law, when you raise money from a group of passive investors, put a promoter or manager in charge, and everyone expects to profit from that person’s efforts, the arrangement can amount to an investment contract — which is a security. Canada’s leading test comes from Pacific Coast Coin Exchange v. Ontario Securities Commission (Supreme Court of Canada, 1978): it asks whether there is a common enterprise and whether investors are led to expect profits significantly from the efforts of others.

This line can fall over either structure. LP units are generally treated as securities; and a passive TIC — where you contribute capital, hand management entirely to a promoter, and wait for distributions — can equally be found to be an investment contract. Once it is a security, raising money from the public requires a prospectus, or reliance on an exemption (for example the accredited-investor or minimum-amount exemptions under NI 45-106).

This is not a theoretical footnote. Selling shares to a circle of friends, relatives, and contacts is exactly the scenario that walks unknowingly into securities regulation. Before you raise a dollar, have a securities lawyer tell you whether it is a security — that answer is far cheaper before the OSC asks than after.

ℹ️This article lays out the structural framework for property and partnership; it is not legal, tax, or securities advice. The specifics — who serves as GP, how the co-ownership agreement is drafted, whether the raise needs a securities exemption, how losses are deducted — must be set by a real estate lawyer, a securities lawyer, and an accountant for your particular deal. My role is to help you ask the right questions early and assemble the right professionals before the money moves.

TIC vs. LP at a glance

■ Tenants in Common (TIC)
· On title: every investor is a registered owner holding an undivided interest
· Liability: each is directly liable as an owner (by share), with no shell
· Tax: flow-through; income and expenses pass straight to each owner
· Exit: transfer your share on your own — and any co-owner can force a sale under the Partition Act
· Control: everyone has a say; major moves need agreement; leans heavily on a co-ownership agreement
· Fits: small groups who trust each other, want to stay owners with a voice, and value the freedom to exit alone

■ Limited Partnership (LP)
· On title: only the GP; limited partners hold units, not a place on the deed
· Liability: GP unlimited, limited partners capped at contribution (as long as they stay out of control)
· Tax: also flow-through, but LP loss deductions are limited by the at-risk rules
· Exit: transfer per the partnership agreement — usually consent, first refusal, or lock-up; no Partition Act forced sale
· Control: concentrated in the GP; limited partners deliberately stay hands-off
· Fits: larger groups with a trusted operating GP, passive investors, and a need for a liability shield

The right way to read this table: you are not looking for the better one, you are choosing which side you can afford to give up. TIC gives you ownership and a free exit and takes peace of mind and a liability shell; LP gives you the shell and the ease and takes your vote and your liquidity.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q

If a few of us buy a commercial building together, isn’t putting everyone on the deed the safest option?

A

Not necessarily. Everyone on the deed is the tenants-in-common (TIC) structure: the upside is that you are genuinely a registered owner and can transfer your own share, but the cost is direct exposure to lawsuits and debts tied to the property, with no liability shell — and under the Partition Act (RSO 1990, c. P.4) any single co-owner can ask a court to force a sale of the whole building. If you want to be a passive investor who only puts in money, a limited partnership (only the GP on title, you as a limited partner) may actually suit you better. Which is safer depends on whether you want owner status or want peace of mind and a liability shield.

Q

In a limited partnership, can a limited partner really lose only what they put in?

A

In principle, yes. Under the Ontario Limited Partnerships Act (RSO 1990, c. L.16), a limited partner’s liability is capped at their capital contribution, and their other personal assets are not reached. But there is a crucial condition: you cannot take part in the control of the business. Once you cross the line into making day-to-day operating decisions, you can be treated as a general partner and exposed to unlimited liability. The Act lets you inspect the books, advise, and act as a surety without losing protection — but actually running the show can void the shield. To keep limited liability, you have to genuinely stay a limited partner.

Q

In a TIC deal, if I only hold 20%, does that mean I carry little risk?

A

The opposite, in fact — a small share does not mean small risk. Under the Partition Act, a minority co-owner has the same right to apply for partition or a forced sale, and so do the others. Worse, if a co-owner divorces, goes bankrupt, or dies, their spouse, creditors, or estate can trigger a forced sale that pulls the whole building in. On liability, you are still a registered owner, so a property lawsuit can name you as a defendant regardless. A small share buys you a small voice, not a small risk.

Q

Do I need to do anything special to sell shares of a commercial property to a circle of friends and contacts?

A

Very likely yes, and this is the step most often missed. Under Ontario securities law, raising money from passive investors, run by a promoter, where everyone expects to profit from that person’s efforts, can amount to an investment contract — a security (the test comes from Pacific Coast Coin Exchange v. OSC, Supreme Court of Canada, 1978). LP units are generally treated as securities, and a passive TIC interest can be found to be one too. Once it is a security, you need a prospectus or a valid exemption (such as the accredited-investor exemption under NI 45-106). Have a securities lawyer weigh in before you raise a dollar — it is far cheaper than being asked about it afterward.

Q

Is this the same tenants in common that comes up with spouses or estates?

A

It is not the same usage. In a marriage or an estate, tenants in common describes how two people co-own a home and how a share passes on death (TIC has no right of survivorship, so the share goes into the estate under the will). This article is about the investment context — a group of investors choosing between TIC and a limited partnership to hold an income property — where the concerns are liability, exit, and securities compliance rather than family succession. The underlying legal concept is related, but the decisions are entirely different.


Discover more from GTA Real Estate Broker | Arthur Zhao

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Continue reading

相关文章Related articles

您好!想了解房产买卖、投资、贷款?随时问我。 点这里开聊 →
Arthur Zhao

AZ 房产 AI 顾问

Arthur Zhao · Real Estate Broker

选个话题快速开始
Powered by AZ Real Estate Partners · 对话用于改进服务