Commercial vs Residential Mortgages: Down Payment, DSCR, Amortization, Recourse
A residential mortgage looks at your personal income. A commercial mortgage asks whether the building can pay for itself. Higher down payment, income-of-the-property underwriting — a different game entirely.
What is the biggest difference between a commercial and a residential mortgage?
The biggest difference is who gets underwritten: a residential mortgage looks mainly at your personal income and credit (GDS/TDS), while a commercial mortgage looks mainly at whether the property can service the debt — measured by DSCR (debt service coverage ratio) = net operating income (NOI) ÷ annual debt service, where A-lenders generally want 1.20–1.25x or higher (CMHC MLI Standard allows 1.10x). Commercial also means higher down payments (typically 20–35%, 65–75% LTV), 15–25 year amortization, and often recourse (a personal guarantee). Per LendCity / CMHC (2025).
Source: LendCity (2025) / CMHC / Canadian commercial lending practice
I’m Arthur Zhao. Clients used to buying their own homes are surprised by three things the first time they hit a commercial mortgage: 30-odd percent down, a bank asking not what their salary is but whether the building’s rent covers the loan, and a demand for a personal guarantee. The bank isn’t being difficult — commercial lending runs on a different logic. It lends to the building’s cash flow; you’re just the backstop. Grasp that logic and you’ll know how to make a commercial deal actually pencil out.
→
→
→
→
Underwriting shifts from ‘you’ to ‘the building’
Higher down payment, lower LTV
Shorter amortization, usually recourse
💡 Commercial lending has no single residential-style “stress test,” but each lender applies its own DSCR coverage standard — that’s effectively its stress test. So don’t start with “how much can I get approved for”; start by computing the building’s honest NOI (with vacancy, management, and a maintenance reserve). If NOI can’t support the DSCR, no amount of down payment buys you the loan you wanted.
Don’t forget the extra diligence costs
Commercial approval also demands things residential doesn’t: a separate commercial appraisal, environmental diligence (a Phase I ESA — especially for industrial, gas-station, or dry-cleaning histories), and heavier legal and commitment fees. These are thousands to tens of thousands in upfront cost — budget for them. If the property has an environmental problem (say soil contamination), the lender may simply decline — which is why the environmental report carries so much weight in commercial diligence.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much down payment does a commercial mortgage need?
Conventional commercial property typically needs 20–35% down (65–75% LTV). Owner-occupied property (51%+ owner use, strong financials) can go higher; 5+ unit multifamily via CMHC MLI Select can be lower, with existing multifamily acquisitions often around 15% with CMHC. Per LendCity (2025). Subject to lender approval.
What is DSCR, and what level do I need?
DSCR (debt service coverage ratio) = the property’s net operating income (NOI) ÷ annual debt service — measuring whether cash flow covers the debt. A-lenders generally want 1.20–1.25x or higher; CMHC MLI Standard can go to 1.10x; stronger cash flow (1.30+) earns better rates. Per LendCity (2025).
Why does a commercial mortgage require my personal guarantee?
Because most small commercial loans are recourse: if the property’s cash flow falls short, the lender can pursue your personal assets, so it wants a personal guarantee as backstop. Only large, institutional-grade deals tend to be non-recourse. Check the scope of the guarantee and whether it can burn off over time before signing.
Does a commercial mortgage have a residential-style stress test?
There’s no single federal stress test, but each lender applies its own DSCR coverage standard — that is its stress test. Before buying, compute the property’s real, conservative NOI; if it can’t support the required DSCR, no amount of down payment gets you the loan amount you wanted.
Beyond the down payment, what are the upfront costs of a commercial mortgage?
A commercial appraisal, environmental diligence (a Phase I ESA, especially for industrial, gas, or dry-cleaning histories), and heavier legal and commitment fees — thousands to tens of thousands combined. Budget for them. An environmental problem (like soil contamination) can lead the lender to decline outright, which is why the environmental report weighs heavily in commercial diligence.
Discover more from GTA Real Estate Broker | Arthur Zhao
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.