跳到主要内容Skip to main content
Commercial · Oct 10, 2026 · 16 min read
📖 Commercial

When a Commercial Tenant Goes Bankrupt in Ontario: What the Landlord Can Still Recover, One Claim at a Time

Back rent, rent for the months the space stays in use, the rest of the term, and the unit itself are four different claims. The Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act and Ontario’s Commercial Tenancies Act treat each one differently.

Arthur Zhao · Broker · AZ Real Estate Partners · 2026-10-10
Quick Answer

When a commercial tenant in Ontario files for bankruptcy or makes a proposal to creditors, what can the landlord still recover?

Treat it as four separate claims, not one debt. Rent owed before the filing is mostly an unsecured claim; in a bankruptcy, up to 3 months of it (plus up to 3 months of accelerated rent, if the lease provides for it) ranks as a preferred claim capped at what the property on the premises sells for (BIA s.136(1)(f)). Rent for using the space after the filing can be required as it falls due, the rest of the term shrinks to a capped accelerated-rent claim or, after a proposal-stage disclaimer, a statutory formula claim, and the unit itself can be kept or assigned by a bankruptcy trustee who elects within 3 months, even against the lease’s terms (Commercial Tenancies Act s.38(2)).

Source: Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. B-3, ss. 65.1, 65.2, 136 and 146 (Justice Laws, current to 2026-09-21); Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7, ss. 38 and 39 (Ontario e-Laws)

I’m Arthur Zhao, a real estate broker with AZ Real Estate Partners. Picture the tenant ledger for one unit in a plaza: several months of unpaid rent at the top, this month’s charge in the middle, and a lease that still runs for years at the bottom. Until the tenant files, that ledger reads like one debt.

The day a commercial tenant goes bankrupt, or files a notice of intention or a proposal under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, the ledger stops being one number. The filing date cuts it into separate claims, and federal and Ontario law give each claim its own rank, its own cap and its own deadline. A landlord who chases the total usually ends up arguing about the wrong line.

So this piece goes line by line: the rent already owed, the rent for the weeks or months the space is still being used, the rent for the rest of the term, and finally the unit itself. Under each, it notes where a bankruptcy and a proposal part ways. It explains how the statutes work; it is not legal advice on any particular lease, and the numbers in the worked example are hypothetical.

Line 1: rent owed before the filing

→

Line 2: rent for using the space after the filing

→

Line 3: rent for the rest of the term

→

Line 4: the unit itself (keep, assign, hand back)

Two procedures share one starting line

Everything below turns on the filing date, so it helps to be clear what each procedure is.

Bankruptcy. The tenant makes an assignment or is made bankrupt by court order. A licensed trustee takes over the tenant’s property, sells it, and pays creditors in the order set out in BIA s.136.

A Division I proposal. The tenant stays in business and offers creditors a deal. It often starts with a notice of intention (NOI) under BIA s.50.4(1). The proposal must then be filed within 30 days; the court can extend that by up to 45 days at a time, to a maximum of five months beyond the first 30 days (s.50.4(9)). If the deadline is missed, s.50.4(8) deems the tenant to have made an assignment, which is a bankruptcy. A proposal the court refuses to approve has the same result under s.61(2).

That last point matters to a landlord: a proposal can turn into a bankruptcy partway through, and the rules for each line below change with it.

Line 1: rent already owed on the filing date

In a bankruptcy: a small preferred slice, the rest unsecured

Once the tenant is bankrupt, BIA s.69.3(1) stops creditors from pursuing their own remedies for debts that are provable in the bankruptcy. Unpaid rent becomes a claim against the estate.

Part of that claim jumps the queue. According to the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (current to 2026), s.136(1)(f) gives the landlord a preferred claim for arrears for the three months immediately preceding the bankruptcy, plus accelerated rent for up to three months after it, but only if the lease gives the landlord a right to accelerated rent. Three conditions sit on that preference:

  • The cap. The total payable under s.136(1)(f) cannot exceed the realization from the property on the leased premises. If the unit holds little of value, the preferred claim is worth little, whatever the arrears.
  • Secured creditors first. Section 136(1) opens with “Subject to the rights of secured creditors,” so a lender with security over the inventory or equipment ranks ahead of the whole list.
  • The overflow. Under s.136(3), a creditor whose claim is restricted by s.136 ranks as an unsecured creditor for the balance. Arrears older than three months, and anything above the cap, fall into that pool.

Ontario’s Commercial Tenancies Act lines up with this: s.38(1) restricts the landlord’s preferential lien for rent to the three months before and three months after the assignment, and from then on only for as long as the trustee keeps possession.

If you had already seized goods for rent. BIA s.73(4) requires property under seizure for rent to be handed to the trustee once the trustee produces a certified copy of the bankruptcy order or assignment. The costs of the distress are secured on that property; the sale proceeds, less those costs, go to the trustee.

In a proposal: the arrears are frozen in place

After an NOI, BIA s.69(1) imposes a similar stay: no creditor may pursue a remedy against the tenant or its property to recover a claim provable in bankruptcy.

The bigger change is to the lease itself. Under s.65.1(1) and (2), once an NOI or proposal is filed, nobody may terminate or amend the lease, or claim accelerated payment or forfeiture of the term, by reason only that the tenant is insolvent, that it filed, or that it has not paid rent for a period before the filing. Section 65.1(5) makes any lease clause to the contrary of no force or effect, so an insolvency-default clause in your lease does not get around it.

The pre-filing arrears are dealt with alongside the tenant’s other pre-filing debts in whatever the proposal offers. There is one escape valve: under s.65.1(6), a party to the agreement can ask the court to declare that these protections do not apply, or apply only in part, if it shows they would likely cause it significant financial hardship.

💡 My own view: the word “preferred” in s.136(1)(f) leads landlords to overestimate what they will get back. The preference is not a claim on the tenant’s money in general; it is capped by what the goods, fixtures and stock inside your unit sell for, and secured lenders get paid first. Before assuming three months of rent is coming back, ask what is actually on the premises and who already holds security over it.

Line 2: rent for the period the space is still being used

Current rent is a different claim from back rent

A filing does not mean the space goes quiet. A trustee may run a liquidation from the unit; a tenant in a proposal usually keeps trading from it. That use is paid for on different terms from the arrears.

In a bankruptcy. CTA s.38(1) keeps the landlord’s claim running “so long as the assignee retains possession of the premises,” and both CTA s.38(1) and BIA s.136(1)(f) say that any accelerated rent paid to the landlord is credited against the occupation rent the trustee owes. In other words, the landlord does not collect both for the same months. Note also CTA s.39(1): the trustee’s occupation of the unit while needed for the estate is not treated as an election to keep the lease.

In a proposal. BIA s.65.1(4)(a) says the stay does not prevent anyone from requiring immediate payment for the use of leased property provided after the filing of the NOI (or of the proposal, if no NOI was filed). Rent for using the space after the filing date is therefore not frozen with the arrears. The statute does not carve out the 30-day notice period that follows a lease disclaimer, which suggests the same rule applies while that notice runs; that is my reading of the text, not a provision that says so in terms.

Line 3: rent for the rest of the term

In a bankruptcy: accelerated rent, if the lease provides for it

For the unexpired term, the only statutory preference is the one already covered in Line 1: up to three months of accelerated rent under BIA s.136(1)(f), only if the lease gives that right, and inside the same cap tied to the property on the premises. The trustee can also give written notice to surrender possession or disclaim the lease (CTA s.39(1)).

Whether a landlord can prove anything beyond that for the years left on a disclaimed lease is not answered by any single section of the BIA or the CTA, and I am not going to guess at it here. If the remaining term is long and the rent is significant, that is the question to put to insolvency counsel early.

In a proposal: the tenant can walk away, and the claim is set by formula

BIA s.65.2 is a tool only the proposal process has. Between the NOI and the filing of the proposal, or on filing the proposal, an insolvent commercial tenant may disclaim the lease on 30 days’ notice to the landlord in the prescribed manner (s.65.2(1)).

  • Challenging it. The landlord has 15 days after being given notice to apply to court for a declaration that s.65.2(1) does not apply (s.65.2(2)). The court must refuse that declaration if it is satisfied that the tenant could not make a viable proposal without disclaiming this lease and its other disclaimed leases (s.65.2(3)).
  • No acceleration. Once disclaimed, the landlord has no claim for accelerated rent (s.65.2(4)(a)).
  • The claim. The proposal itself must say which claim the landlord may file: its actual losses from the disclaimer, or a formula amount equal to the lesser of (i) the first year’s rent after the disclaimer takes effect plus 15% of the rent for the remainder of the term, and (ii) three years’ rent (s.65.2(4)(b)).
  • The vote. The landlord’s claim goes either into a separate class of similar landlord claims or into a class of unsecured creditors that includes non-landlords, and the landlord votes in that class for the amount proven (s.65.2(5) and (6)). The court can settle the classes on application (s.65.2(7)).

The proposal, not the landlord, picks between the actual-loss route and the formula. Read that clause in the proposal before deciding how to vote.

⚠️The 15-day window runs from notice, not from the disclaimer date. Under BIA s.65.2(2), a landlord who wants to challenge a lease disclaimer in a proposal must apply to court within 15 days after being given notice. The disclaimer itself takes effect on 30 days’ notice, so the challenge deadline arrives first.

Hypothetical: the s.65.2(4)(b) formula on two lease lengths

8 years left after the disclaimer
15 years left after the disclaimer
Assumed rent (hypothetical, flat)
$6,500/month = $78,000/year
$6,500/month = $78,000/year
(i)(A) First year’s rent
$78,000
$78,000
(i)(B) 15% of the remaining term
15% × 7 years × $78,000 = $81,900
15% × 14 years × $78,000 = $163,800
(i) Total
$159,900
$241,800
(ii) Three years’ rent
$234,000
$234,000
Formula claim (lesser of i and ii)
$159,900
$234,000
💡 These are illustrative numbers, not a real file. The formula uses “the rent provided for in the lease,” so a lease with step-ups produces different figures, and the formula applies only if the proposal offers it instead of actual losses. With flat rent, part (i) is the smaller figure until the term left after the first year passes 13 years and 4 months (15% of that equals two years’ rent); beyond that, three years’ rent becomes the ceiling.

Line 4: the unit itself

In a bankruptcy: the trustee has three months to decide

This is where Ontario law does most of the work. BIA s.146 says that, apart from the s.136 priority ranking and ss. 73(4) and 84.1, a landlord’s rights are determined by the law of the province where the premises are. In Ontario that brings in the Commercial Tenancies Act.

According to the Commercial Tenancies Act, s.38(2), the trustee may, despite any provision in the lease, elect in writing within three months to keep the premises for all or part of the unexpired term and any renewal, on the lease’s terms and paying the lease rent. After paying the landlord all arrears, the trustee may then assign the lease to someone who:

  • covenants to observe and perform the lease terms;
  • will run a business that is not reasonably more objectionable or hazardous than the tenant’s; and
  • is approved by a judge of the Superior Court of Justice as fit and proper to be put in possession.

Alternatively, before making that election, the trustee can give written notice surrendering possession or disclaiming the lease (CTA s.39(1)). Disputes under ss.38 and 39 go to a Superior Court judge on application (s.39(3)).

The BIA has its own route as well: under s.84.1, on the trustee’s application, the court can order a bankrupt’s rights and obligations under an agreement assigned to a person who agrees to the assignment. It cannot do so unless all monetary defaults, other than those arising only from the bankruptcy, insolvency or a failure to perform a non-monetary obligation, will be remedied by a date the court sets (s.84.1(5)).

Subtenants. If the tenant had sublet with your written consent and the trustee surrenders, disclaims or elects to assign, the subtenant may elect in writing within three months to stand in a direct lease with you, at a rent no lower than it was paying the tenant and, if the head-lease rent was higher, at that higher rent (CTA s.39(2)).

Corporate versus individual tenants. BIA s.84.2(2), which stops a landlord from terminating a lease by reason only of the bankruptcy or pre-bankruptcy arrears, applies to a bankrupt individual. Where the tenant is a corporation, s.84.2 is not the governing provision; CTA s.38(2) is.

In a proposal: the tenant keeps the unit unless it disclaims

In a proposal the tenant, not a trustee, stays in the unit and keeps trading, and s.65.1 prevents the landlord from terminating or amending the lease by reason only of insolvency, the filing, or pre-filing arrears. Those are the only listed grounds; how the stay interacts with a different default arising after the filing is a fact-specific question for counsel, and I would not act on it without advice.

The unit comes back to the landlord through a s.65.2 disclaimer (Line 3). An assignment can also go to court: BIA s.66(1) applies the Act’s provisions to proposals with necessary modifications, and s.66(1.1) adds that, on an application under s.84.1, the court must also consider whether the trustee approved the proposed assignment.

Security deposits and personal guarantees sit outside these four lines and are covered in separate articles linked below.

ℹ️Three different three-month periods. In a bankruptcy, s.136(1)(f) looks back three months for arrears and forward up to three months for accelerated rent; CTA s.38(2) gives the trustee three months to elect to keep the premises; CTA s.39(2) gives a consented subtenant three months to elect a direct lease. They are separate clocks.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q

Can I change the locks or seize the tenant’s stock for unpaid rent after they file?

A

For rent owed before the filing, generally no: BIA s.69(1) (after an NOI) and s.69.3(1) (after a bankruptcy) stop creditors from pursuing remedies against the tenant or its property for claims provable in bankruptcy. Goods already under seizure for rent must be handed to the trustee under s.73(4), with the costs of the distress secured on them. Rent for using the space after an NOI is different: s.65.1(4)(a) lets you require immediate payment for it.

Q

Does my tenant’s bankruptcy automatically end the lease?

A

No section of the BIA or the Commercial Tenancies Act ends the lease automatically on bankruptcy. Under CTA s.38(2), the trustee has three months to elect in writing to keep the premises, despite any lease provision to the contrary, and under s.39(1) it can instead give written notice surrendering possession or disclaiming the lease. The trustee’s occupation while it administers the estate does not count as an election to keep it.

Q

My tenant sublet part of the unit with my consent. What happens to the subtenant?

A

Under Commercial Tenancies Act s.39(2), if the trustee surrenders, disclaims or elects to assign the lease, a subtenant you approved in writing can elect in writing within three months to become your direct tenant. It must covenant to pay you at least the rent it was paying the tenant, or the head-lease rent if that was higher. Disputes go to a Superior Court judge under s.39(3).

Q

If a tenant in a proposal walks away from a long lease, how much can I claim?

A

Under BIA s.65.2(4), you lose any claim for accelerated rent, and the proposal decides whether you claim your actual losses or a formula amount: the lesser of the first year’s rent after the disclaimer plus 15% of the rent for the rest of the term, and three years’ rent. Your claim is then voted in a landlord class or a general unsecured class under s.65.2(5) and (6).

Q

What happens to my claim if the tenant’s proposal falls apart?

A

If the proposal is not filed within 30 days of the NOI or any court extension, BIA s.50.4(8) deems the tenant to have made an assignment in bankruptcy, and a court refusal to approve the proposal has the same effect under s.61(2). From that point the bankruptcy rules apply, including the s.136(1)(f) preferred claim and, through s.146, Ontario’s Commercial Tenancies Act. Section 65.2(8) states that the proposal-stage disclaimer rules do not affect s.146 in the event of bankruptcy.


Discover more from GTA Real Estate Broker | Arthur Zhao

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Continue reading

相关文章Related articles

您好!想了解房产买卖、投资、贷款?随时问我。 点这里开聊 →
Arthur Zhao

AZ 房产 AI 顾问

Arthur Zhao · Real Estate Broker

选个话题快速开始
Powered by AZ Real Estate Partners · 对话用于改进服务