One of the most common questions I hear from buyers is: “The MPAC assessed value is $820,000, but the asking price is $1,050,000 — isn’t that overpriced?” It’s a fair question, and it reveals one of the most persistent misconceptions in Ontario real estate. MPAC assessment and market value are two entirely different things, built for different purposes, calculated using different data. Mixing them up is one of the fastest ways to make a costly mistake at the negotiating table.
The formula is straightforward: Property Tax = CVA × Municipal Tax Rate. The CVA is not designed to tell you what a property is worth in today’s open market — that’s a job for comparable sales analysis.
This means your neighbour’s property, your target home, every residential property in Ontario is still assessed against market conditions from a decade ago. In those ten years, Greater Toronto Area home prices rose dramatically, then partially corrected. The MPAC number captures none of that movement.
Neither situation means the seller is wrong, the buyer is being deceived, or the market is broken. It simply means MPAC and market value are measuring different things at different points in time.
When you’re deciding whether to make an offer and at what price, the tool you need is a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) — a side-by-side review of recent sales of comparable properties in the same neighbourhood. That’s what I prepare before every showing. MPAC is useful for estimating your annual property tax bill and nothing more.
The same trap works in reverse: don’t assume a property is overpriced just because MPAC’s number is lower than the list price. In most GTA markets, that’s the normal relationship.
If you own a property and believe the MPAC CVA is inflated — causing you to overpay property tax — you have two formal options:
Request for Reconsideration (RfR)
File directly with MPAC. This process is completely free. The deadline for residential properties is typically March 31 of the tax year (for 2026, the deadline was March 30, 2026). MPAC will review your assessment and respond in writing within 180 days, with up to an additional 60 days if needed.
Assessment Review Board (ARB)
If MPAC’s RfR decision doesn’t satisfy you, you have 90 days from that decision to appeal to the ARB, an independent tribunal. For residential properties, you must complete the RfR step first before ARB will accept your appeal.
For the 2026 tax year, MPAC continues to use the fully phased-in January 1, 2016 valuation as the basis for all residential assessments across Ontario. New construction and properties with significant improvements will be assessed at what those improvements would have been worth in 2016 — which is increasingly difficult to determine accurately as construction costs and market conditions have diverged substantially from that base year.
Understanding the difference between assessed value and market value isn’t just academic — it directly affects how confidently you can negotiate, how accurately you can budget for ownership costs, and whether you’re overpaying property tax year after year. If you have questions about how to interpret your MPAC notice or want a proper CMA before making an offer, reach out anytime.
Ontario Property Tax
Current Value Assessment
Buyer Mistakes
Request for Reconsideration
Ontario Real Estate
CMA Analysis
Discover more from GTA Real Estate Broker | Arthur Zhao
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.